- The Foundry: Conservative Policy News Blog from The Heritage Foundation - http://blog.heritage.org -
Medicaid Expansion in Arkansas: A Fig Leaf, Not a Solution
Posted By Dan Greenberg On April 30, 2013 @ 5:05 pm In Obamacare | Comments Disabled
As action to stop Obamacare languishes in Washington, the debate continues at the state level. Heritage is hosting a series of health care reports from our allies in the states to provide an up-close view of state-level action regarding Obamacare.
The states play an important role in protecting citizens against this flawed federal health care law–from challenging the health care law before the Supreme Court, to resisting efforts to establish Obamacare exchanges or expand a failing Medicaid program, to offering alternative proposals that will ensure citizens are not left abandoned when the federal law collapses.
Today, Dan Greenberg—President of the Advance Arkansas Institute—updates Foundry readers on developments in Arkansas.
A bipartisan alliance succeeded in convincing the Arkansas legislature to expand Medicaid. That was because enough Republicans were won over by the legislation’s theoretically pro-market design. However, a closer look suggests a textbook case of a beautiful theory slain by ugly facts. 
Republican proponents of expansion claimed that the proposal was fundamentally different from a traditional Medicaid expansion, because it would enroll the new Medicaid clients in private insurance through the state’s Obamacare exchange. They dubbed it the “private option,” and argued that private plans would provide better care at lower cost.
When the arrangement was first proposed, it was greeted with cautious optimism in some quarters . But that optimism predated the “Good Friday memo ” from the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services, which clarified that any Medicaid expansion provided through private coverage would still have to conform to standard Medicaid benefit requirements and cost-sharing limitations.
In plain English, the maneuver Arkansas was contemplating would gain the state no additional flexibility on benefits or cost sharing beyond the (very limited) scope allowed under current federal Medicaid rules.
Thus, the notion that the “private option” could somehow produce significantly lower costs and better patient outcomes relative to traditional Medicaid became highly doubtful. At best, it would simply be a variant on the existing and common strategy of states contracting with private managed care companies to deliver Medicaid benefits. Yet, while the policy differences were vanishingly small, to the point of nonexistent, the rhetorical shift was enough for the pro-expansion forces to eke out a win in the end. Given that, it is worth deconstructing the rhetoric offered in support of the Arkansas plan.
In sum, the advocates of Medicaid expansion in Arkansas built bipartisan political support by linking the Medicaid expansion to conservative reform. Republican Senator Jeremy Hutchinson argued on the Senate floor that the private option was a “down payment” on future reform of “entitlement programs.”  Republican Senator Jason Rapert argued that the private option was “essentially what we all say we want—Medicaid block grant funding  to allow states to innovate for their own populations.” Indeed, Representative Collins argued that the private option would allow Arkansas to “transcend Obamacare ” while Speaker Carter insisted that a vote for the private option is “a vote against Obamacare .”
Such statements are less analytical than rhetorical—and to those who understand the basic workings of Medicaid and Obamacare, they are unpersuasive. In any event, such statements were enough to let Governor Beebe achieve his goal of expanding Arkansas’s Medicaid program.
Dan Greenberg, the President of the Advance Arkansas Institute, is both a former member of the Arkansas legislature and a former Heritage Foundation analyst.
Article printed from The Foundry: Conservative Policy News Blog from The Heritage Foundation: http://blog.heritage.org
URL to article: http://blog.heritage.org/2013/04/30/medicaid-expansion-in-arkansas-a-fig-leaf-not-a-solution/
URLs in this post:
 Image: http://blog.heritage.org/wp-content/uploads/MedicaidChart_ARKANSAS_FINAL1.jpg
 a beautiful theory slain by ugly facts.: http://www.anvari.org/fortune/Miscellaneous_Collections/255425_the-great-tragedy-of-science-the-slaying-of-a-beautiful-theory-by-an-ugly-fact.html
 cautious optimism in some quarters: http://www.forbes.com/sites/aroy/2013/04/01/the-arkansas-obamacare-medicaid-deal-far-less-than-it-first-appeared/
 “Good Friday memo: http://blog.heritage.org/2013/04/03/administration-rules-out-deals-on-medicaid-expansion/
 is dead: http://www.thecitywire.com/node/27001#.UXa8GSuf6Kk
 categorically different: http://talkbusiness.net/2013/03/so-where-are-we-in-the-medicaid-debate/
 off the Medicaid rolls.: https://twitter.com/CollinsARK/status/321321830562529281
 linked: http://swtimes.com/sections/news/politics/arkansas-legislature-house-gop-leader-wants-postpone-decision-health-care
 in conjunction with: http://www.arktimes.com/ArkansasBlog/archives/2013/03/01/house-speaker-attempts-to-tie-capital-gains-tax-cut-with-medicaid-expansion
 increase net state government revenue: http://www.thearkansasproject.com/the-verdict-is-in-time-for-conservatives-to-abandon-the-private-option/
 they would not take effect until future budget years: http://www.thearkansasproject.com/et-tu-republicans-no-meaningful-tax-cuts-for-arkansans/
 contractual commitments that Medicaid expansion creates: http://www.advancearkansas.org/storage/hotelcalifornia.print.pdf
 a one-way street: http://online.wsj.com/article/SB10001424127887323393304578358513300121002.html?mod=wsj_valetbottom_email
 the “Hotel California” problem: http://www.thearkansasproject.com/will-the-medicaid-expansion-triggers-fire/
 “down payment” on future reform of “entitlement programs.”: http://www.arktimes.com/ArkansasBlog/archives/2013/04/17/senate-to-take-up-healthcare-expansion-appropriation-at-1100-am
 Medicaid block grant funding: http://www.thearkansasproject.com/i-want-to-believe-this-isnt-obamacare/
 transcend Obamacare: https://twitter.com/CollinsARK/status/321255385501683712
 a vote against Obamacare: http://www.thearkansasproject.com/speaker-carter-we-have-always-been-at-war-with-eastasia/
Copyright © 2011 The Heritage Foundation. All rights reserved.