• The Heritage Network
    • Resize:
    • A
    • A
    • A
  • Donate
  • Why Won’t the Euro Crisis Just Go Away?

    The European euro/debt/growth/banking/identity crisis is entering its third year. With so many summits, toasts, tense conference calls, and self-congratulatory pronouncements of ultimate success by Europe’s brightest lights, why won’t the crisis just go away? Instead, it is ramping up as interest rates on Spanish and Italian debt rise to critical levels, signaling the end of another respite.

    The answer, of course, is that in three years, Europe has yet to face up to the deepest causes and underlying consequences of a failed experiment. But before heaping scorn on Europe’s timidity, we should acknowledge first the dreadful consequences sure to follow from correcting their mistake. And have a little sympathy for the citizens of Europe today, who while compounding their errors must nevertheless suffer through the consequences of a grand mistake made nearly a generation ago.

    The European crisis has no obvious start date, but a good candidate is April of 2009, when the European Union told France, Spain, Ireland, and Greece to reduce their budget deficits in the wake of the credit crisis. That’s an interesting group of countries. The Irish were bailed out at the end of 2010 after the Irish government essentially bankrupted the country by bailing out its own bankrupt banks. Greece has been bailed out repeatedly to little effect as it slides into deep depression. Spain is now under enormous pressure, and France is about to fire its government, if the polls hold true.

    Much has happened since those early days as the crisis ebbed and flowed. European leaders constructed enormous bailout funds and a phony fiscal union. The European Central Bank morphed from respectable central bank into a monstrosity outside known definition. And countries at greatest risk of default have driven their economies toward depression while slashing government spending and hiking taxes in a vain attempt to appease capital markets, which are just playing them for fools.

    For all this, it does appear that official Europe is beginning to understand what it will take to make the crisis go away. The clue is the language now spoken in polite company. Three phrases in particular merit noting: divergence, economic growth, and the wonderfully antiseptic expression of “domestic devaluation.”

    An underlying theory of the euro currency experiment was the possibility of banding together countries of very different development levels in a common market with a common currency. The belief was that this configuration would set economic forces driving toward “convergence.” Poorer, less competitive countries would grow especially rapidly and would converge on the more advanced, like Germany and France. It didn’t happen. It’s now obvious that, if anything, these policies led to a devastating divergence. Devastating to all, but especially to the divergent, like Greece and Italy.

    Early on in the crisis, affrighted by the depressing effects of fiscal consolidation, as it is known in the salons, or slashing spending and hiking taxes, as it is known everywhere else, European leaders developed a welcome newfound appreciation for economic growth policies. But then these new converts acted as though they could just pick up said policies like so many medications at the apothecary, and that the new policies would work miraculously overnight; wrong on both counts.

    What would work? Cutting taxes, not raising them, especially on productive activity. This is the one policy they could adopt quickly, but chose not to.

    In contrast, other policies that really matter—freeing labor markets and eliminating other regulatory costs—take time. Labor market reforms like cutting minimum wages, minimum vacation time, hire and fire rules, etc., quickly run afoul of entrenched union powers. Yet, even if the reforms are pushed through in full, years must pass to harvest an appreciable effect.

    The expression “domestic devaluation” is the most interesting and most telling of all. To understand what this really means, consider its cousin, the external devaluation. This is familiar enough: A nation with a large and unsustainable trade deficit and a fixed exchange rate simply devalues the currency, setting a much lower exchange rate. Voila—instantly, workers are more competitive, because wages (when measured in foreign currencies) have been slashed, but the workers don’t see the cuts directly, so there’s little chance of rioting in the streets. Foreign goods cost more, but that just means buying more domestic stuffs. The trade deficit heals, and the economy recovers smartly. While the side effects can be troublesome, external devaluation works.

    Euroland countries can’t just adopt an external devaluation amongst themselves because they don’t have their own currencies; they have the euro. So they have to resort to domestic devaluation, a fancy term for slashing wages and other costs directly. And not just by a percentage point or two; by 20 percent, 30 percent or more. This is something workers tend to notice, especially if they have loud and easily agitated unions.

    Why won’t the euro crisis just go away? Even if the Greeks et al adopted every effective growth policy known to man, they would still be left with their unsolved devaluation problem. No bailout fund of any size can solve it. No amount of bank recapitalization can solve it. The countries at issue must decide which devaluation to pursue—external or internal. The former requires leaving the euro. The latter likely leads to revolution and then a euro exit. No, the euro crisis won’t just go away.

    Posted in Featured [slideshow_deploy]

    7 Responses to Why Won’t the Euro Crisis Just Go Away?

    1. Laurie Davis says:

      We just spent to weeks in Ireland and were surprised to find things in such bad shape. Everything was very expensive, closed stores and boarded up homes were sadly evidence of a distressed economy. I was even more surprised to see that the hotels, restaurants and stores were staffed by Eastern Europeans instead of the Irish who seemed to need jobs. We were told that they lived in 'dormatories' at the hotels and worked long hours. I do not profess to know anything about world economics, but it seems to me that bringing in immigrants by the thousands at low wages, long hours etc. will onl serve to depress wages for the people who live there. I think this may be going on throughout the EU….probably for a long time; but it surprised me.

      • sakara says:

        possibley illegal aliens in ireland of all places…!

        Before the financial crisis, I was reading articles of how the Irish were proud that the English were now coming to Ireland for menial jobs, and there were photos of Black Africans (vs Black Irish) in Ireland.

    2. Another other aspect of social disarray is emigration , which has a particularly nasty aspect as it is those with the best, the most valuable skills who are emigrating . Like the suitcases of banknotes fleeing the distressed economies , social capital is fleeing as well . These are the Portugese nurses fleeing to Germany , the greek architects to Australia and perhaps the Celtic tigers back to NYC as the did in the 70's . This is another feature of the death spiral as the talented and valuable persons leave what remains are those less able to compete and more in need of government monies , all the while paying nothig into the system . And one need not travel all the way to Europe's distant shores to observe this , our own state of California is well down the road to Eurosclerosis .

    3. John C. Davidson says:

      My fears regarding this issue & our own problems leads me to believe that they (Socialists) are awaiting the move towards the creation of a world currency.

    4. Stirling says:

      This is what Socialism looks like people, the end result is always a currency that can not support it's government's largess (entitlements). The Euro is a basket of countries that rely on the "Collective" currency of many. At some point the Pozni-Scheme fails because the "Takers" outnumber the "providers."

      People like George Soros is getting just what he wants, which is a "Managed Decline" in which America, the EU, and other "Western nations" eventually are bled dry in Debt.. Leading the way to a "Global" solution to fix the "Worlds" problem.

    5. Carol, AZ says:

      Yes, the massive policy to open-up Europe's' border and also utilize the Euro throughout Europe 's economy, was done to remove borders, in the spirit of openness.
      It's been a disastrous policy.
      Europe also allowed thousands of unskilled to enter from third world country around the world with focus from Muslim countries.
      What has been left out of this article is the chaos created in all European countries based on this belief system, and their laws. Rarely reported here; Terrorist attacks in, England, Germany, Italy, Holland, Belgium are all by Muslim backed extremism., called terrorism.
      Unless you have European roots, which I do, few Americans understand that; "one has everything to do with the other."

    6. Pingback: El porqué la eurocrisis no va desaparecer tan fácilmente | Heritage Libertad

    Comments are subject to approval and moderation. We remind everyone that The Heritage Foundation promotes a civil society where ideas and debate flourish. Please be respectful of each other and the subjects of any criticism. While we may not always agree on policy, we should all agree that being appropriately informed is everyone's intention visiting this site. Profanity, lewdness, personal attacks, and other forms of incivility will not be tolerated. Please keep your thoughts brief and avoid ALL CAPS. While we respect your first amendment rights, we are obligated to our readers to maintain these standards. Thanks for joining the conversation.

    Big Government Is NOT the Answer

    Your tax dollars are being spent on programs that we really don't need.

    I Agree I Disagree ×

    Get Heritage In Your Inbox — FREE!

    Heritage Foundation e-mails keep you updated on the ongoing policy battles in Washington and around the country.

    ×