• The Heritage Network
    • Resize:
    • A
    • A
    • A
  • Donate
  • Ecotality Examined: SEC Subpoena for Stimulus-Backed Company Revealed

    Part one of a three-part series.

    Scribe has obtained a copy of a Securities and Exchange Commission subpoena sent to Donald Karner, former CEO of Ecotality North America (formerly called eTec), the subsidiary of a company that recieved roughly $115 million in stimulus grants to manufacture charging stations for electric vehicles.

    Despite its federal funding, and shout-outs from both President Obama and Energy Secretary Steven Chu, Ecotality fell on hard financial times in 2010. It is now under investigation by the SEC. The company recently failed to file its fourth quarter earnings report with the SEC, citing the “unreasonable effort or expense” that would be necessary.

    In all, Ecotality looks to be yet another stimulus-backed green energy company backed by strong political ties, but with limited financial viability outside of its large government-enabled revenue stream. Rep. Andy Harris (R-MD) has started asking questions of Chu regarding Ecotality’s substantial federal funding.

    Scribe will further explore Ecotality, its backing from the Energy Department, and the SEC investigation in a three-part series this week.

    In the interests of public knowledge, we first present a copy of the subpoena sent to Karner on December 15, 2011 It requests reams of information, including all communications with 18 employees of and investors in Ecotality. (Note: procedural documentation unrelated to the SEC investigation has been removed from the end of the document.)

    Ecotality Subpoena

    As the subpoena makes sure to note, the SEC has not accused anyone at Ecotality of doing anything illegal. Rather, the agency is requesting information that may be used in its investigation.

    The list of employees and investors on page 12 merits particular attention. Ecotality CEO Jonathan Read, one of 18 individuals named in the subpoena, joined the company in 2006 (more on him tomorrow). His son Colin is the company’s vice president of corporate development. While Colin Read is not named in the subpoena, his wife and father-in-law, Kathleen and Gary Weinkauf, are.

    There are other family connections on the list of individuals. Harold Sciotto was formerly Ecotality’s treasurer, secretary, and director. He and nephew David Sciotto are both listed in the subpoena.

    Another pair of names stick out: Min Zhu and Yuqing Xu, the owners of Zhu-Xu Charitable Remainder Trust, part of a group of investors that together hold 9.99% of Ecotality’s stock. Zhu and Xu, husband and wife, founded online communication company Webex, which was later purchased by Cisco Communications.

    Zhu has something of an interesting history: he has been named in numerous lawsuits by a former business partner, Michael Zeleney. Citing sworn deposition by Zhu’s daughter Erin that her father raped her at the age of 14, Zeleney claims that he was threatened by anonymous individuals claiming to represent Zhu and Webex in response to legal action filed against Min Zhu relating to those rape allegations.

    Daryl Magana, also named in the subpoena, is both an Ecotality board member and a partner at Cybernaut Capital, an investment firm founded by Zhu.

    Many of these individuals will be explored in greater detail in part 2 of this series.

    Posted in Featured, Ongoing Priorities, Scribe [slideshow_deploy]

    8 Responses to Ecotality Examined: SEC Subpoena for Stimulus-Backed Company Revealed

    1. Thank you for your work in delving into this, even as far back as October 2011.

      I wrote a post on this last week at Bog Government, so I'm interested to see what else you have to share on this topic: http://www.breitbart.com/Big-Government/2012/03/2

    2. Laurie says:

      Thanks guys. There are always investigations, investigations and investigations. Why is nobody EVER indicted? Hmmmmmmmmmmm? We The People never hear "the rest of the stories". Are they investigating themselves. Sure seems like it. This has to STOP yesterday.

    3. lichief says:

      I think we are getting use to the fact that the politicians and their pals are above the investigations and laws…

    4. Mark says:

      You should put together a quick summary of all these green stimulus boondoggles, their ties to the White House and the amount of taxpayer money lost. It would need to be updated every few days as it seems they're dropping like flies. Maybe you could take bets on the total lost by the election.

    5. To paraphrase P.T. Barnum, I don't care what the bloggers say about me as long as they spell my name right.

    6. Ken Smith says:

      Ecotality also got matching private funds in addition to the federal money, so add another 100+ million that went into their cookie jar.

    7. Ken Smith says:

      Ecotality also got matching private funds in addition to federal money, so add another 100+ million that went into their cookie jar.

    8. bubba boy says:

      Ecotality has posted both their 4th and 1 st quarter results..They had a profit 1.25 million in the first quarter

    Comments are subject to approval and moderation. We remind everyone that The Heritage Foundation promotes a civil society where ideas and debate flourish. Please be respectful of each other and the subjects of any criticism. While we may not always agree on policy, we should all agree that being appropriately informed is everyone's intention visiting this site. Profanity, lewdness, personal attacks, and other forms of incivility will not be tolerated. Please keep your thoughts brief and avoid ALL CAPS. While we respect your first amendment rights, we are obligated to our readers to maintain these standards. Thanks for joining the conversation.

    Big Government Is NOT the Answer

    Your tax dollars are being spent on programs that we really don't need.

    I Agree I Disagree ×

    Get Heritage In Your Inbox — FREE!

    Heritage Foundation e-mails keep you updated on the ongoing policy battles in Washington and around the country.

    ×