• The Heritage Network
    • Resize:
    • A
    • A
    • A
  • Donate
  • Majority of Physicians Don’t See Eye to Eye with the AMA on Obamacare

    Obamacare changes the health care system in several ways that harm physicians. It also fails to address the pivotal issues facing physicians today—for example, low government reimbursement rates that fail to cover the cost of care, or the need for state-by-state medical malpractice reform.

    It should have come as a surprise, then, that during the health care reform debate, the American Medical Association (AMA) emerged as one of the new law’s supporters. But rather than symbolizing physicians’ support for the left’s health care overhaul, the AMA’s stance on Obamacare just proves how detached the organization has become from physicians’ best interests. A recent phone survey of physicians conducted by Jackson and Coker, a division of Jackson Healthcare, affirms the growing gap between the AMA and the physicians it is intended to represent. The survey showed:

    • Only 11 percent of the physicians surveyed agreed that “the AMA’s stance and actions represent my views.” Of those who are members of the AMA, only 40 percent agreed.
    • 13 percent of all physicians, and just 35 percent of AMA members, agreed with the AMA’s position on health reform; 70 percent disagreed.
    • Of those who had dropped their AMA membership, 47 percent said it was because of the AMA’s support for Obamacare, and 43 percent who said AMA’s ideology was too far to the left.
    • Only 15 percent of physicians considered the AMA a successful advocate of physicians’ issues. 75 percent of physicians surveyed said that “the AMA no long represents physicians; physicians need a more representative voice.”

    Physicians are clearly concerned about the future of the medical profession and the health care system as a whole. In a paper describing Obamacare’s impact on doctors, Heritage expert Robert Moffit writes, “Based on earlier polling and surveys of physician sentiment, none of this should be surprising. The new law does not address physicians’ most pressing concerns, such as tort reform, and it worsens the already painful problems with third-party payment and government red tape.”

    Obamacare ignores what is best for physicians and their patients. The new law does nothing to address the flawed sustainable growth rate formula, which requires a reduction in Medicare reimbursement rates for doctors. Congress delays the formula’s effects every year because of the impact it would have on seniors’ access to care. If Congress fails to pass a “doc fix” this year, payment rates will fall by 29.4 percent, making it more difficult for physicians to continue seeing Medicare patients. The AMA has long called for a permanent solution, but supported Obamacare even though it did not include one.

    At the same time, Obamacare also expanded Medicaid coverage to include as many as 25 million additional Americans. This will crowd out existing private coverage and require physicians to treat more patients at the reimbursement rates offered by Medicaid, which in many cases do not even cover the cost of providing services. Finally, the new law expands the Medicare bureaucracy, increasing the rules, regulations, and guidelines that physicians must follow.

    Physicians’ lack of support for the new law confirms that to achieve the kind of reform that will most benefit doctors and their patients, Congress will have to scrap Obamacare and start over.

    Posted in Obamacare [slideshow_deploy]

    7 Responses to Majority of Physicians Don’t See Eye to Eye with the AMA on Obamacare

    1. Bobbie says:

      obama continues to reflect ignorance of the concerns of the people. he continues to act in opposition to the will of the people. where is and has the money been going? repeal obamacare. it's unconstitutional and more entrapment then benefiting. the doctors that don't see eye to eye with the AMA are the doctors true to their cause. Doctors we can't afford to lose!!! AMA is clearly in it for government involvement to hide behind and tax dollars money. Couldn't make it in the private sector of accountability. Get government out!!!!

    2. West Texan says:

      I respect the many years of training, long work hours and practice challenges faced by physicians. But their political opinion regarding health services is no more qualified than the rest of ours. The AMA obviously hides a far-left progressive agenda behind the face of medicine. No different than the AARP's political viper in the grass. According to your numbers, it sounds like a majority of Docs do know what it takes to run a small business. May the Almighty reward their good efforts.

    3. Jay Mershon says:

      Anyone surprised? This was known during the Obamacare debate/debacle, but poorly covered by the President's Press Corps, oh, I mean the MSM. AMA is just another organization compromised by the hunger for power and influence and no longer representative of the people they claim to represent. When I was growing up the AMA was considered the premier physicians and health advocates. No longer.

    4. Bobbie says:

      Heritage, I think I misused a word in my comment. meant "apocalyptic," not "apoplectic." if possible, could you correct? sorry…

    5. Laura Henning says:

      During the debates much was made of the AMA supporting Obamacare with the suggestion that the entire medical profession also was behind it. Two years ago I was made aware of the fact that just a small percentage of physicians belonged to the group, usually young docs just out of medical school and who had not yet gone into specialties which have their own professional associations. As usual the Annointed One was misleading the public. Remember the docs sporting their White House issued lab coats while they attended a propaganda meeting in the Rose Garden?

      • Bobbie says:

        I agree Laura! Totally misleading! Who would've thunk the AMA were doctors without a prayer in the private sector? Scary to think they'll be the "general" health care providers at top pay with no accountability…

    6. Dennis L. says:

      It would be interesting to know how many physicians actually belong to the AMA in 2011. I am sure it is a minority and if so, the AMA should no longer be touted as the official voice of practicing physicians. The current trend in healthcare seems to be in the direction of forcing doctors to become paid employees. I believe that the age of private solo or small group practice will soon become extinct. Then what? Corporate practice with a nine to five mentality? Lesser quality since competition will have been essentially removed from the equation?

    Comments are subject to approval and moderation. We remind everyone that The Heritage Foundation promotes a civil society where ideas and debate flourish. Please be respectful of each other and the subjects of any criticism. While we may not always agree on policy, we should all agree that being appropriately informed is everyone's intention visiting this site. Profanity, lewdness, personal attacks, and other forms of incivility will not be tolerated. Please keep your thoughts brief and avoid ALL CAPS. While we respect your first amendment rights, we are obligated to our readers to maintain these standards. Thanks for joining the conversation.

    Big Government Is NOT the Answer

    Your tax dollars are being spent on programs that we really don't need.

    I Agree I Disagree ×

    Get Heritage In Your Inbox — FREE!

    Heritage Foundation e-mails keep you updated on the ongoing policy battles in Washington and around the country.

    ×