• The Heritage Network
    • Resize:
    • A
    • A
    • A
  • Donate
  • Overpopulated Rhetoric

    Neglected news out of the Crazy from the Heat Department is word that the global overpopulists are in a terrific snit because soccer superstar David Beckham and his wife, Victoria, dare to continue producing children. Talk about a crime against nature.

    Fortunately, as The Wall Street Journal noted, the Beckhams had the good sense not to get hot under the collar after the birth of their fourth child drew a scolding from Population Matters, a tone-deaf British nonprofit.

    Heritage’s Chuck Donovan quickly rose to the Beckhams’ defense. Donovan penned an op-ed for the McClatchy-Tribune wire before Simon Ross, wiggy chief exec of Population Matters, could catch his breath from all the trash talking.

    “The ‘optimum pop’ people are relentless,” Donovan writes, adding:

    “They want mandatory ‘free’ contraceptives in every U.S. insurance plan, non-negotiable federal dollars for Planned Parenthood and more support for abortion globally. They’re willing to slur and slander the David and Victoria Beckhams of the world for loving and wanting to have children.”

    The Beckhams “are very bad role models with their large families,” Ross had huffed to the British press. “There’s no point in people trying to reduce their carbon emissions and then increasing them 100 percent by having another child.”

    Using the ridiculous to illustrate the serious, Donovan reasons:

    “Set aside Ross’ appallingly bad math. The most that one more child in the Beckham household could do to their carbon footprint is increase it by one-sixth. But Ross has plenty of sympathizers among elite political figures, both in the United Kingdom and around the world…

    “Today, astonishingly low birth rates prevail in countries across Europe.   Greece, a nation struggling to maintain its welfare state, has an estimated total fertility rate this year of 1.38 children per woman. … Embracing the darkest visions of the ‘population bomb’ movement, many nations in the West saw their proposed solutions detonate on their own shores.  The role of declining population in making their social contracts unaffordable receives too little attention in the debt and deficit debates.”

    But back to the ridiculous. Not only that, Chuck, did Simon Ross’ lot ever think how culturally bereft we’d be without the youngest or next-to-youngest of many a family?

    For starters, no Mark Twain, who was the sixth of seven children. And no Stephen Colbert, youngest of 11. The late great Michael Jackson (King of Optimum Pop) was the eighth child of Joseph and Katherine Jackson. Janet, their youngest, was No. 10.

    The Left – and the Academy Awards – would be a far more serious place without Jim Carrey or Billy Crystal.

    With the population curve bending toward zero, all the more reason to applaud parents who, as Donovan writes, “are willing to defy the crowd and — like the Beckhams — bend it back.”

    Posted in Culture [slideshow_deploy]

    5 Responses to Overpopulated Rhetoric

    1. kENNETH says:

      There is no over population. You can fit the entire world population in Texas and still have room. The only problem in this world as far as hunger,medicine,clothing,housing and jobs are the governments. They impede the the gifts from other governments and reject the help from religious organizations. They fail to educate for fear of loosing power over the ones they oppress. Those who impress the over population of the world are selfish people. They are here for themselves and their own advances. Little do they know they will only be here on this earth but for a short time. May God help them when it's their time for judgement. KEN.

    2. Bobbie says:

      Congratulations to the Beckhams cause if there's any population loved it's those that are provided by their parents.

      Reminds me of the American government and Mexicans proudly stating Mexicans will be the greatest populated in America! No doubt! Too many don't provide for or take responsibilities in their freedom of choice to procreate. Too many come in unlawfully with government accommodations. History will reflect this…

    3. @SnoBurd says:

      If Mr. Ross feels it necessary to berate someone for having too many children, why doesn't he go after Octomom, or Kate (from Kate plus 8)? Having 4 is not a serious offense, 14 should be, especially when there is no husband around, nor any prospects.

    4. Al from Fl says:

      I remember in my high school days (early 50's) that the word was overpopulation would lead to world starvation and a prediction that society would starve to death in 20 years. Their concern then was the high birth rate in the U.S. Today we haven't starved to death and we are in danger of disappearing as a nation because of a low birth rate. Bad science is still bad science and the global nuts in the U. N. are using the U.N. and others to milk all the funds they can get.

    5. AlfromFl says:

      Over 50 years ago, in my highschool years, the prediction among the "experts" was that the high birthrate would cause world wide starvation in 20 years because of over population and insufficient abilty to produce eough food. These fool "experts" seem to still be around – they never learn.

    Comments are subject to approval and moderation. We remind everyone that The Heritage Foundation promotes a civil society where ideas and debate flourish. Please be respectful of each other and the subjects of any criticism. While we may not always agree on policy, we should all agree that being appropriately informed is everyone's intention visiting this site. Profanity, lewdness, personal attacks, and other forms of incivility will not be tolerated. Please keep your thoughts brief and avoid ALL CAPS. While we respect your first amendment rights, we are obligated to our readers to maintain these standards. Thanks for joining the conversation.

    Big Government Is NOT the Answer

    Your tax dollars are being spent on programs that we really don't need.

    I Agree I Disagree ×

    Get Heritage In Your Inbox — FREE!

    Heritage Foundation e-mails keep you updated on the ongoing policy battles in Washington and around the country.

    ×