• The Heritage Network
    • Resize:
    • A
    • A
    • A
  • Donate
  • Conservatives Beware: The Boehner Plan Leads to Tax Increases

    Conservatives have a clear objective: Debt limit legislation should drive down federal spending on the way to a balanced budget, while preserving the ability to protect America, and without raising taxes.  The plan suggested by Speaker of the House John Boehner fails to meet that objective — indeed, it sets America up for tax hikes.

    The Boehner plan has two steps.  The first step cuts spending by $1.2 trillion — but over ten years, and, as usual with these plans, the deep cuts come in the later years, which makes it less likely that they will ever occur.  Moreover, the cuts do not get under control the ever-growing spending in the entitlement programs that continuously drive up America’s debt.   In the first step, the American people get only a little bit of spending cuts now, but President Obama gets authority to borrow $1 trillion.  He gets $325 billion immediately and $675 billion upon making a later request, a request that automatically takes effect as long as the President keeps the support of the one-third of a House of Congress necessary to sustain a veto of a disapproval resolution, support he would have.  So, the first step of the plan has iffy cuts in spending, but guarantees big increases in borrowing.

    The second step in the plan is a set of recommendations from a new dozen-member joint select committee of Congress.  The committee’s recommendations to Congress would not be subject to amendments and would get a straight up-or-down vote.  The plan directs the committee to propose reductions in the deficit by at least $1.8 trillion over 10 years.  The government runs a deficit when it spends more than it takes in from Americans as taxes, and the government has run deficits in most years for decades.  As always, there are two ways to reduce a bloated government’s deficit — the right way of cutting spending and the wrong way of hiking taxes.  While the second step of the Boehner plan may produce some useful spending cuts, the second step also allows the Committee to propose raising taxes as part of its unamendable, fast-track legislative package.  Thus, the second step greases the way for tax hikes.

    Tax hikes in a weak economy slow economic growth and kill jobs.  As students of American history (or the movie “Ferris Bueller’s Day Off”) know, enactment of the tax hike known as the Smoot-Hawley Tariff Act during the Great Depression hurt the already weak economy and made unemployment worse.  Job-killing tax hikes in the current weak economy, as millions of Americans go without jobs and the unemployment hovers above 9 percent, will have a similar effect.  However good the intentions of the drafters of the Boehner plan may have been, the plan sets up America for higher taxes and fewer jobs.  Conservatives should continue to fight plans that either hike taxes now or set America up for tax hikes in the future.

    For decades, Congress has promised on vote after vote we will really get spending under control “next time,” and, as all those “next times” went by with that same empty congressional promise, the public debt mounted.  The message of the 2010 election was clear — cut the size and spending of government now — and the voters who sent that message deserve better treatment from their government.

    The House of Representatives took a step in the right direction last week when it passed the Cut, Cap and Balance Act by a vote of 234 to 190.  But the Boehner plan to retreat from the Cut, Cap, and Balance Act is a long step in the wrong direction.  The House Leadership should step back and recover its focus on the objective. The time to put America on the path to getting control of federal spending and borrowing on the way to a balanced budget, while preserving our ability to protect America, and without raising taxes, is now.

    Posted in Economics [slideshow_deploy]

    8 Responses to Conservatives Beware: The Boehner Plan Leads to Tax Increases

    1. Daniel says:

      None of the 6 Republicans appointed to the supercommittee would vote for any tax hike. That basically debunks your entire premise

      • Mike, Wichita Falls says:

        I bet none of the 6 Democrats will vote for any real, immediate spending cuts, so there will be another stalemate. The real committee "appointed" by the people to solve this problem is all of Congress not just one to which Congress defers for political cover.

    2. roy heflin says:

      AGAIN Reps of Both Parties proves they think Americans Are DUMB! Cuts of 1.6 trillion Over 10 Years? Don't we have a yearly Budget Deficit of 1.2 trillion = over 10 years 12 trillion ; WHAT A JOKE!

    3. Reasonable says:

      You say there's are right way by reducing spending and a wrong way by increasing taxes. Why cant we find a compromise that includes both at a moderate rate ?

    4. Chas says:

      "Tax hikes in a weak economy slow economic growth and kill jobs" indeed they do, but tax is 'due and payable'relative to both corporate and individual gain. Create the jobs ,have the tax. Stop creating fictional gain and trying to tax it. The economy has to review ongoing fiscal policy setting it every 1-3 years, (the elected government has to decide) so the balance of what is taxed and consequences for all such levy with limits are set. In turn it has to see where national gain will rise and lean country towards a better relative gain over tax, which allows for development.

    5. BRENDA CUMMING says:


      • ESR says:

        That is like saying it is bad fiscal practice for businesses to sell stocks on the market, or for homeowners to take out a mortgage to buy their house.

        Borrowing money is sensible as long as you use the money for investments that increase your worth and you can pay your debts.

        What we need now is to strengthen the US economy so revenue goes up and we can pay our debts.
        What we don't need now is to weaken our economy by cutting government spending and investment.

    6. Philip Young says:

      There seems to be one course of action which is not receiving enough attention: Job Creation. America has become very hostile for small or emerging businesses. Besides the wholesale slaughter of America’s manufacturing base, with over 7 million jobs lost to overseas manufacturing. Rebuilding our job market would provide revenue, some taxes, reduce the burden on entitlement programs and establish global confidence in America. The stock market would recover and economic recovery would be on its way. Work is involved and so few politicians will endorse this process. Perhaps because many of these same politicians are responsible for losing American Jobs in the first place.

    Comments are subject to approval and moderation. We remind everyone that The Heritage Foundation promotes a civil society where ideas and debate flourish. Please be respectful of each other and the subjects of any criticism. While we may not always agree on policy, we should all agree that being appropriately informed is everyone's intention visiting this site. Profanity, lewdness, personal attacks, and other forms of incivility will not be tolerated. Please keep your thoughts brief and avoid ALL CAPS. While we respect your first amendment rights, we are obligated to our readers to maintain these standards. Thanks for joining the conversation.

    Big Government Is NOT the Answer

    Your tax dollars are being spent on programs that we really don't need.

    I Agree I Disagree ×

    Get Heritage In Your Inbox — FREE!

    Heritage Foundation e-mails keep you updated on the ongoing policy battles in Washington and around the country.