• The Heritage Network
    • Resize:
    • A
    • A
    • A
  • Donate
  • Will President Obama Abide by Court's Decision and Suspend Obamacare?

    Justice for John Yoo and Jay Bybee

    This week, Judge Roger Vinson of the United States District Court for the Northern District of Florida became the second federal judge to strike down Obamacare’s individual mandate. In doing so, Vinson struck down the entire law concluding “the individual mandate and the remaining provisions are all inextricably bound together in purpose and must stand or fall as a single unit.” Judge Vinson’s decision has prompted a long overdue national debate over the limits of the federal Leviathan. Specifically, is there anything, any form of human activity or, more importantly, inactivity, that lies beyond the heavy hand of Washington?

    According to Heritage legal expert Robert Alt, there is no question that Judge Vinson’s declaratory judgment binds the parties to the suit, that is, the plaintiffs – 26 states and the National Federation of Independent Business – and the defendant – the federal government. Vinson’s decision, moreover, is effective immediately (both the order and the mandate have issued). Translation: an HHS bureaucrat who so much as lifts his pen on behalf of any provision of Obamacare against the 26 states or NFIB members, is violating the court order and risks a possible finding of contempt of court.

    Now, the White House faces a simple and straightforward choice: Will President Obama abide by a decision arrived at by a federal district court judge pursuant to all applicable federal procedural niceties, or, unilaterally ignore the rule of law, as he has done in the past?

    The President’s top lawyers no doubt are working overtime on a legal rationalization for ignoring Judge Vinson’s ruling. This so-called “non-acquiescence” argument would allow the bureaucratic wheels to spin in, at a minimum, the 24 states not party to the suit and, depending on the audacity of their argument, possibly in all 50 states.

    One can almost sense the disdain at 1600 Pennsylvania Avenue. “We will never let one petty district court judge,” the irate White House official may say, “and a Reagan appointee no less – stop such a historic law from benefiting every American.” This was certainly the attitude demonstrated when President Obama repeatedly ignored federal court orders to cease his economically-crippling moratorium on domestic oil exploration last year.

    States that were party to the suit against Obamacare certainly give credence to Vinson’s decision. “Judge Vinson declared the health care law void and stated in his decision that a declaratory judgment is the functional equivalent of an injunction,” Wisconsin Attorney General J.B. Van Hollen said in a statement. “This means that, for Wisconsin, the federal health care law is dead — unless and until it is revived by an appellate court.”

    There are other ripple effects. One example: how will budget scorekeepers such as the Congressional Budget Office “score” the budgetary implications of suspending Obamacare’s massive expansion of the Medicaid program?  Fiscally-pressed states, for example, could scale back their Medicaid eligibility levels and still comply with federal law.

    Washington, moreover, is about to engage in a series of gargantuan budget battles – the President and congressional leaders will unveil their respective budget blueprints for fiscal year 2012 and beyond shortly; the continuing resolution that funds government agencies expires on March 4th; and mounting government debt will push up against the debt ceiling later in the Spring. The budgetary “baseline” that lawmakers use to plot long-term health expenditures – with Medicaid being chief among them – is crucial to any budget debate. Also, employee benefit managers in NFIB firms with more than 50 employees no doubt are on the phone now with their health insurance providers, hoping to renegotiate downward the recent upward spike in premiums that greeted them as the first manifestation of Obamacare.

    At a minimum, lawmakers may view the March 4th expiration of the continuing resolution as an opportunity to send a clear message to the President – uphold the law and comply with Judge Vinson’s decision. No ifs, ands, or buts.

    Posted in Obamacare [slideshow_deploy]

    9 Responses to Will President Obama Abide by Court's Decision and Suspend Obamacare?

    1. Wayne, St. Louis, Mo says:

      Enjoyed your article. I think the entire health care law needs to be overhauled but the ultimate conclusion will be that we will eventually have to go to a single-payer system. I know people do not want to hear that but it is inevitable. Thanks,

      Editor http://www.speakingforamericans.com

    2. Mary of New York Cit says:

      If the Egyptian people can take to the streets and change their national government, we can, if necessary, take to the streets and change the course of ObamaCare!

    3. Jax Tico Jacksonvill says:

      What will we do if and when this president ignores this court decision? How should We The People react? Should we take to the streets like Egypt? No, we are a civil society, but doesn't this throw our government into a constitution crisis? This guy will ignore what he doesn't like and smile at us as if everything is OK because he is immune to prosecution. Short of impeachment proceedings, this guy will continue to do what he wants when he wants. My only hope is that the republicans in congress have the backbone to hold this marxist regime to task for what they have been doing and attempting to do to the fabric or our nation. We the People are so much stronger than any progressive gives us credit for. We will bend and bend until we will bend no more and I fear we are getting close to that point. No violence just justice and the American way. We are a Constitutional Republic and even those who have voted democrat in the past know that our way of life is in jeopardy because of this president and his cronies. freewethepeople.com

    4. Bobbie says:

      I don't understand why the president gets an option? It's done alot of damage to cash, costs and careers. Where the medical industry is losing staff, Obama already has his preferential hirees.

      Stop all funding immediately upon the ruling! Now is yesterday! Set the standards for free market insurance. Let the industry freely discriminate against anyone who omits pertinent information regarding the application of insurance.

      Let the people be responsible for themselves and insurance companies available to those that choose to be insured. Those that don't take the responsibilities regarding their individual health including costs, can be on obamacare. Siphon out the irresponsible.

    5. Pingback: Tweets that mention Will President Obama Abide by Court’s Decision and Suspend Obamacare? | The Foundry: Conservative Policy News. -- Topsy.com

    6. Pingback: Tweets that mention The Foundry: Conservative Policy News. -- Topsy.com

    7. Pingback: » Financial News Update – 02/02/11 NoisyRoom.net: The Progressive Hunter

    8. Pingback: New Consumer Buying Guides on DVD Movies by Mail, Diamond Rings, and Teeth Whitening Launches | iPhone 3G Review

    9. linda says:

      Is Mr Obama above the law ? Does he get the choice of whether he abides by our laws or not ? Someone needs to find him in contempt and get on with it ! I am ill with this administration and the destruction they have brought upon our great country ! He should have been vetted totally while he was running for president. The main stream media let our America and our people down ! He is a socialist to the core and demonstrated that in its many years prior to his campaign.He delights in the destruction of our capitalist system and the greatness of our country being soiled throughout the world ! I fear for our country …He must be defeated in 2012 !!

    Comments are subject to approval and moderation. We remind everyone that The Heritage Foundation promotes a civil society where ideas and debate flourish. Please be respectful of each other and the subjects of any criticism. While we may not always agree on policy, we should all agree that being appropriately informed is everyone's intention visiting this site. Profanity, lewdness, personal attacks, and other forms of incivility will not be tolerated. Please keep your thoughts brief and avoid ALL CAPS. While we respect your first amendment rights, we are obligated to our readers to maintain these standards. Thanks for joining the conversation.

    Big Government Is NOT the Answer

    Your tax dollars are being spent on programs that we really don't need.

    I Agree I Disagree ×

    Get Heritage In Your Inbox — FREE!

    Heritage Foundation e-mails keep you updated on the ongoing policy battles in Washington and around the country.

    ×