- The Foundry: Conservative Policy News Blog from The Heritage Foundation - http://blog.heritage.org -
Florida’s Education Reforms: The Rest of the Story
Posted By Lindsey Burke On December 6, 2010 @ 5:00 pm In Education | 9 Comments
The education establishment is pushing back against common-sense education reforms that have proved successful in Florida. Dr. Madhabi Chatterji, a professor at Columbia Teachers College, has written a paper critical of a Heritage study  of these reforms by Matthew Ladner, Vice President of Research at the Goldwater Institute and I. Last week, The Washington Post’s education blog, The Answer Sheet , devoted itself to presenting Dr. Chatterji’s critique. We are now responding.
To review: Our study concluded that education reforms implemented under then-Governor Jeb Bush have produced significant academic gains, particularly among minority students. Florida’s Hispanic students, for example, are now outperforming or tied with the overall reading average for all students in 31 states.
The change-averse may wish to quibble over the details or agonize over just what reform did how much of what. But the bottom line is that in 1998—the year before Bush instituted his reforms—47 percent of Florida fourth-graders scored “Below Basic” on the [National Assessment of Educational Progress] fourth-grade reading test. In 2009, that number was down to 27 percent. That is a 42 percent decline in the fourth-grade illiteracy rate in the span of a decade.
Dr. Chatterji suggests that Florida’s policy barring social promotion of third-graders artificially inflates Florida’s fourth-grade reading scores. Ironically, she criticizes our paper for not conducting a literature review even as she fails to do so herself. Had she reviewed the literature, she would have found that former Heritage Foundation Senior Analyst Dan Lips and Ladner had already addressed this, her main claim, over a year ago in the pages of Education Next .
The reality of the Florida policy reforms is far more complex and positive than Dr. Chatterji would have you believe:
Dr. Chatterji also argues that other policies such as class size reduction and preschool vouchers—both enacted in Florida by ballot initiative—may have caused the improved scores. There is little or no reason to believe these policies helped improve Florida’s reading scores.
There is a five-year delay between attending preschool and reaching the fourth-grade. The preschool program was passed in 2002, but it wasn’t open to all five-year-olds until 2005. The earliest year it could have an impact on fourth-grade reading scores is 2011.
Florida’s class size amendment, passed in 2002, had a very slow implementation. Any effects from this measure would have shown up only in the later years, if at all. Moreover, a review of the literature shows that the empirical evidence on class size reduction is overwhelmingly negative.
The bottom line is that Florida’s education reform model, particularly the retention policy, incentivized schools to place a greater focus on early childhood literacy in grades K, 1, 2, and 3. That is why the number of students scoring low enough to be retained in the first place has been cut in half and Florida’s NAEP scores have improved.
As for us, we recommend that policymakers look to Florida as an example of successful education reform with its proven mixture of transparency, accountability, and parental choice.
Co-authored by Matthew Ladner, Ph.D., Vice President of Research, The Goldwater Institute.
Article printed from The Foundry: Conservative Policy News Blog from The Heritage Foundation: http://blog.heritage.org
URL to article: http://blog.heritage.org/2010/12/06/florida%e2%80%99s-education-reforms-the-rest-of-the-story/
URLs in this post:
 Image: http://www.foundry.org/wp-content/uploads/floridaschool.jpg
 Heritage study: http://www.heritage.org/research/reports/2010/09/closing-the-racial-achievement-gap-learning-from-floridas-reforms
 The Answer Sheet: http://voices.washingtonpost.com/answer-sheet/accountability/is-progress-in-florida-schools.html
 Education Next: http://educationnext.org/demography-as-destiny-2/
Copyright © 2011 The Heritage Foundation. All rights reserved.