• The Heritage Network
    • Resize:
    • A
    • A
    • A
  • Donate
  • The Attack on Alexander Lebedev: A Blow to Russia’s Rule of Law and Freedom of the Press

    This week, two seemingly unconnected events took place in Moscow. Yet, considered together, they have are of tremendous importance and serve to weaken the rule of law in Russia.

    Last Tuesday, imprisoned former Russian oil tycoon Mikhail Khodorkovsky delivered a passionate speech at the end of his kangeroo court proceedings about the corroding lawlessness plaguing his country. As Khodorkovsky addressed the court, masked Russian police SWAT teams armed with Kalashnikovs raided the National Reserve Bank in Moscow. The bank belongs to Alexander Lebedev, another billionaire political opponent of the Putin-Medvedev “tandemocracy.”

    According to international media reports, the businessman left Russia right after the raid. He may have done the right thing: when Khodorkovsky refused to leave, he ended up with two prosecutions for a combined requested sentence of 23 years in the GULAG. Other businessmen targeted by the state left the country—and also kept their freedom.

    After the bank invasion its managers said that the investigators did not make it clear what they were looking for, but they accessed computer files and records. The agents from Russia’s FSB secret service and the interior ministry said that the search was related to the bank’s takeover of another Russian financial institution, Rossiysky Kapital. Nevertheless, the search looks more like a personal warning to Lebedev, and was reminiscent of the 1990s, when Russian authorities and competing business owners abused such raids to threaten their opponents and rivals.

    Mr. Lebedev owns three British newspapers, but more importantly, he publishes the best opposition Russian investigative paper, Novaya Gazeta, which employed the journalist Anna Politkovskaya. Anna’s 2006 murder is still unsolved. Several other Novaya Gazeta editors and journalists were also murdered.

    Lebedev also owns interest in the Russian airline Aeroflot, and the country’s largest potato producer. However, it is Lebedev’s politics and media involvement which are more likely to have triggered a goon raid, not his other business interests: Just a few hours before the raid, Novaya Gazeta published the first interview with Khodorkovsky and his imprisoned business partner Platon Lebedev (no relation).

    And two years ago, Lebedev’s tabloid was abruptly shut down after it published a story claiming Vladimir Putin’s marriage was on the rocks and that then Russian president was involved in a romantic relationship with 27-year-old Olympic champion Alina Kabayeva.

    Lebedev is also a politically active: In 2008, while a Duma deputy, he tried to form a new oppositional party together with the ex-Soviet leader Mikhail Gorbachev. The Kremlin blocked the attempt, and Lebedev and Gorbachev got nowhere.

    When the Moscow mayor Luzhkov was fired by president Medvedev, Lebedev claimed publicly that Moscow should be the model for the rest of Russia, electing its mayors and governors instead of having the President appointing them like in czarist times.

    A former KGB foreign intelligence officer (he served in London in the late 1980s), Lebedev also criticized the ex-mayor of Moscow Yuri Luzhkov, and his wife Yelena Baturina for the wide-spread allegations of multi-billion dollar corruption. He recently called for Britain to investigate Luzhkov, who may seek asylum in London.

    Now, Lebedev believes that the recently fired mayor may have ordered the raid. At the same time, it is obvious that the Kremlin may have its reasons to dislike Lebedev, especially with the looming 2011 Duma elections—not to mention the 2012 presidential elections. His partner, Gorbachev, recently announced that if the government policies don’t change, Russia will have a social explosion by 2015.

    Thus the raid on the National Reserve Bank was possibly caused by a combination of its owner’s political and media activities which crossed the paths of powerful clans in Russia. Wealthy businessmen, who think for themselves and act independently, are particularly dangerous for the regime, as they compete with the Kremlin for power and popularity.

    Will Lebedev’s fate be the same as Khodorkovsky’s? Or he will leave Russia and end up in London, like another exiled oligarch, Boris Berezovsky?

    Meanwhile, the Kremlin knows that this latest scandal may spoil the business climate in Russia and scare off foreign investors. But, with oil prices continuing to climb, it seems not to care.

    The Obama Administration and the U.S. business community should keep an eye on extra-legal activities of the Russian authorities, businesses, and organized crime, especially when considering Russia’s membership in the WTO. While the development of bilateral U.S.-Russia economic ties and Russia’s integration into the global economy are laudable, we should not ignore blatant violations of accepted business practices and democratic norms by corrupt elements of the Russian government and law enforcement.

    Posted in International [slideshow_deploy]

    4 Responses to The Attack on Alexander Lebedev: A Blow to Russia’s Rule of Law and Freedom of the Press

    1. RAGOZZI says:

      I can't believe how some people can pour so much dirt onto Russia and it's leaders and not even feel ashamed. Actually, they even feel proud doing it. Do you have any specific factsM, supporting your point of view, Mr. Cohen ???? I haven't seen any so far.

    2. ZviadKavteli says:

      Clearly, the raid was ordered by the Kremlin. The ex-Mayor Luzhkov has no power to do that any more. Leaving Russia was a smart decision, however Lebedev should continue criticism of Kremlin. Lebedev has a lot to lose. Most of his property is Russian real estate which cannot be moved or easily sold. Therefore, most of his property is held hostage by the Kremlin. Nevertheless, Lebedev should not cave in to Putin blackmail.

    3. R Holland, Chandler, says:

      Don't turn your back on Putin, he will put a knife in it.

    4. Hanna Orr says:

      I am surprised that the article refers to "corrupt elements" in Russias business, authorities and organized crime.

      If the head of the country (Mr Putin) can amass a fortune of $41 billion, all of it from shady deals, this is a testimony to the fact that te entire power structure in Russia is thoroughly corrupt. There is no boundary between big business, authorities and organized crime. They are one and the same.

      I sure hope that the really powerful figures in the West are aware of real face of Russia and the media statements like this one only conceal the fact that the West knows Russia is a lawless bully, with no respect for law, human rights (including life of its own citizens), democracy or even common decency. I sure hope that nobody trusts Russias fake declaration of "commmittment" to modernisation, democracy blah, blah, blah.

      As a citizen of an Eastern European country, which was historically always threatened by Russia, I hope the West is able to see the real motives and counteract the hostile policies of what still remains very much an evil empire.

      Lawlessness, authoritarian rule, corruption and lack of respect for the individual and human rights are deeply rooted in Russia.

      The power structures in Russia are interested in one goal only, which is personal enrichment of those close to power and continued political influence in foreign affairs, which takes place by byllying and generally paranoid and hostile acts towards rest of world.

      The only hope of Russia's neighbours is continued alliance with the West, which albeit not perfect, is the only counterbalance to this global villain.

    Comments are subject to approval and moderation. We remind everyone that The Heritage Foundation promotes a civil society where ideas and debate flourish. Please be respectful of each other and the subjects of any criticism. While we may not always agree on policy, we should all agree that being appropriately informed is everyone's intention visiting this site. Profanity, lewdness, personal attacks, and other forms of incivility will not be tolerated. Please keep your thoughts brief and avoid ALL CAPS. While we respect your first amendment rights, we are obligated to our readers to maintain these standards. Thanks for joining the conversation.

    Big Government Is NOT the Answer

    Your tax dollars are being spent on programs that we really don't need.

    I Agree I Disagree ×

    Get Heritage In Your Inbox — FREE!

    Heritage Foundation e-mails keep you updated on the ongoing policy battles in Washington and around the country.