• The Heritage Network
    • Resize:
    • A
    • A
    • A
  • Donate
  • The Worst Federal Disaster Response in Our Nation's History

    President Obama wishes everyone would stop talking about the oil spill. His federal government’s response has been incompetent at best, malevolent at worst. Yet, lacking any evidence of a credible response, Obama still sent Carol Browner to the Gulf on a victory lap last week after oil stopped appearing on beaches and the water’s surface. But while the Obama administration is doing victory laps, more news of their botched efforts are coming to light.

    Case in point: reports out today show that the government tried to silence scientists from the University of South Florida who had discovered a 6-mile-wide plume of oil in the deepest recesses of the Gulf.

    USF Marine Sciences Dean William Hogarth told the St. Petersburg Times: “I got lambasted by the Coast Guard and NOAA when we said there was undersea oil.” He further said that government officials told him to retract any public statements and compared it to being “beat up” by the government.

    According to the Times, Hogarth was not the only one bullied by the Obama administration. Oceanographers at the University of Southern Mississippi drew similar conclusions about underwater plumes. Oceanographer Vernon Asper said: “We expected that NOAA would be very pleased…NOAA instead responded by trying to discredit us.”

    Why would the Obama administration try to silence environmental scientists? Because its victory lap would be less victorious if millions of barrels of oil are still lurking in the Gulf.

    Mother Nature, though, might throw a wrench in the president’s oil spill cleanup cover-up machine. If a hurricane hits, the oil that lurks beneath the deep dark see will surely become evident. But what happens then?

    The AP reported on Monday that if a hurricane hits the Gulf and oil is displaced onto land, a “new Obama administration edict requires that the oil be tested before it can be cleaned.” Translation? That means even further delays in the oil spill cleanup.

    Let’s put that in perspective: 1) The Obama administration wasted months of clear weather delaying skimmers, barriers and clean-up responses, leaving the Gulf vulnerable to oil being washed ashore in hurricane season; and 2) The Obama administration now won’t allow residents to even clean the oil ‘onshore’ that their incompetence allowed to happen.

    This is simply incredible. Or, as LSU Environmental Studies Professor Ed Overton said: “This is insane. You don’t have to hold up the cleanup just because you’re waiting on a crazy lab analysis.” Former FEMA Director David Paulison agreed, saying: “I just don’t believe it’s a workable plan.”

    The government claims this step is necessary to determine that the oil is actually a result of the BP spill so it can be reimbursed for any response. Y’know, in case the oil happens to be from that oil spill in Michigan last month. As the AP reports: “[I]t also could cause frustrating delays and prevent residents from returning to their homes while the government figures out who pays the bill.”

    Residents of the Gulf have had enough of this bureaucratic neglect. Charlotte Randolph, president of the Lafourche Parish, La., told the AP she will have it cleaned up, regardless of government edict. Randolph said: “The assumption will be that the oil belongs to BP…I don’t care what the federal government says.”

    And that sums up the total response in a nutshell. State and local residents have continually taken matters into their own hands to direct resources and manage response, while the White House has made a show of eating Gulf shrimp on the South Lawn.

    But it doesn’t stop there. Today, after 57 days of silence from President Obama and BP, details of their backroom liability deal have emerged from the White House. (Parenthetically, 57 days is apparently the new standard of White House transparency.) These latest details again prompt us to consider how little of the $20 billion BP oil spill relief fund will actually reach victims of the spill.

    As The Heritage Foundation reported in July, BP is claiming a tax deduction worth roughly $9.9 billion as a result of the backroom deal. This means that taxpayers are either now on the hook for part of the costs of cleanup, if costs truly reach $20 billion, or that another negotiation is necessary. The White House has failed to answer this question, likely because nobody in the White House press briefing room has asked it.

    President Obama knows better than anyone that he has failed the residents of the Gulf. That is why he refuses to step foot in Louisiana, where his job-destroying drilling moratorium continues to take place, despite his own assurances that the spill was overblown and the oil has dissipated.

    Instead, President Obama will spend one night in Florida with the hospitable Governor Charlie Crist (I) who, like the White House press, will not ask him any tough questions. While this political trip may deflect criticism of the president’s Maine vacation last month, the first lady’s vacation in Spain this month, the president’s vacation in Chicago this month or their planned Martha’s Vineyard vacation later this month, it will not display any empathy for the tragedy he has helped create.

    After ignoring two federal court decisions, the Obama administration is once again returning to federal court this week to try to keep his economy-crushing moratorium in place. The current re-issued federal language applies to all floating rigs in the Gulf. Entire cities are losing jobs and livelihoods due to the moratorium — not the spill — and yet President Obama continues to show a callous disregard for the economic catastrophe he has created.

    You can count on one hand the number of times President Obama has addressed the crisis in the Gulf since his bungled Oval Office speech. During that time the federal government has failed the residents of the Gulf time after time. It’s time the Obama White House be held responsible for the worst federal disaster response in our nation’s history.

    Posted in Security [slideshow_deploy]

    14 Responses to The Worst Federal Disaster Response in Our Nation's History

    1. Brad, Chicago says:

      So, the administration has put itself in the best position it knows. If this other oil never surfaces, they will say they got everything cleaned up. If it does become an issue, they will just blame BP for being evil, greedy jerks who failed to protect people. Everything comes down to perceptions; it doesn't matter what really happens, as long as people blame the "right" person (in this case, blame the government for any good and blame BP for any bad).

    2. Michael, Van Buren says:

      We were just there this past weekend. All of the beaches on Grand Isle are CLOSED. Some of the local's have been warned not to fish or go in the water.

      Marsh areas near Venice, LA (Bay Jimmy) are oiled and clean-up crews are still working on a plan to clean these areas as well as the oil that has sunk to the bottom. Crews are worried about the health risks of the chemical Corexit that is being used to break up the oil.

      Pictures from this past weekend can be seen here…
      http://www.trevordowphotography.com/Trevor_Dow_Ph

    3. Fran, St. Louis says:

      So the oil spill now joins the ranks of border security — total failure by the Feds to do the few things they are required to do according to the Constitution. Sorry, I forgot that the Constitution is now considered a terrorist document.

    4. Mike, Hattiesburg says:

      Liberals were SCREEMING after Katrina hit that Bush and Republicans hated African-Americans! Odd that liberals are so conspicuously silent at this time… Not!

    5. Pingback: Too Many Lies | StephensonGroup.org

    6. Billie says:

      American President ignores the peoples concerns of their individual livelihoods that the President neglects for purposes of corruption and complication for his own reasons of power and take-over.

    7. Meremortal says:

      This is one problem with this article. A reader could be easily misled into visualizing the "oil plumes" as lethal solid clouds of oil hulking around under the surface. The plumes are large areas where microdrops of oil exist at quantities of approximately .5 parts per million parts water. Very sensitive instrumentation had to be used to differentiate the plume areas from normal areas. Zooplankton love oil served up in this way, and are happily crunching away on the droplets. Since oil is a natural substance, it can be consumed by some animals and converted to energy. Oil is organic food for zooplankton. Zooplankton is rather important to the food chain, you could look that up. We may see more of certain Gulf fish species in 2-4 years.

      None of this excuses any possible bad behavior by the administration. That is a different discussion.

    8. FactsRule says:

      As I recall, Obama turned away 13 countries who, with their technical expertise, would have got much more oil cleaned up much faster and better. Obama did much more that led to the worst disaster responses in history. Writing about those things would have strengthened this article. It's not too bad, though.

    9. Julie,Winona,Mn says:

      How can people remain so stubbornly blind about this man! the only thing he seems to take seriously is destroying everything we stand for as a country! oh yeah and their globe trotting and expensive parties and vacations!! Sad so sad!! Come on Nov. Everybody needs to put checks on this man!! Vote anybody who doesn't approve of current agenda and pray,pray for us all that there is something left in 2012.

    10. Concerned, Mequon WI says:

      Unfortunately – everything with Obama is political. He couldn't care less about all these issues – he is only interested in re-election. If he is re-elected in 2012 this country will go down in flames. His goal is to have everyone and everything dependent on the government. He wants to be a dictator not a president.

    11. BJ Ft. Myers Fl says:

      What ever happened to the "A Whale" ? There was much to do in the media as this ship could clean up the spill much faster than anything else. I guess the administration decided that it wasn't enviormently safe, or was it not politically safe? This president is a disaster in the making and will continue to make extremely bad decisions. Can you imagine what the media would have said under the Bush Administration. There would be no end to the hue and cry of the media.

    12. Robin, Springfield says:

      This reminds me of a conversation at a dinner table with my step-son when he was small. He knocked over a glass and just watched it. I picked up the glass and started dropping paper napkins on the milk. I said, "When you tip over a glass, pick up the glass right then. Don't think about it, don't just watch it spill, pick it up. It doesn't all instantly flop on the table but it pours. You could have had half a glass full of milk still and just a few napkins would be needed to clean up, but now I have to mop the floor." Even my dear spouse will watch a spill until the wonder and shock of the moment have fully materialized before he moves to do anything. Perhaps the government has people like this at work in the Gulf of Mexico area.

    13. Jack, Portage Michig says:

      Obama is an incompetent Boob. He is doing more to destroy this country that even Jimmy Carter, another incompetent boob.

    14. Marshall, Dameron, M says:

      I am at a loss for words with this administration. It is killing our country by a thousand cuts that nobody will address. If you are an American, you must wake up and put a stop to this cancer in our country whether you are liberal or conservative. Do not be suicidal in your ideaologies.

    Comments are subject to approval and moderation. We remind everyone that The Heritage Foundation promotes a civil society where ideas and debate flourish. Please be respectful of each other and the subjects of any criticism. While we may not always agree on policy, we should all agree that being appropriately informed is everyone's intention visiting this site. Profanity, lewdness, personal attacks, and other forms of incivility will not be tolerated. Please keep your thoughts brief and avoid ALL CAPS. While we respect your first amendment rights, we are obligated to our readers to maintain these standards. Thanks for joining the conversation.

    Big Government Is NOT the Answer

    Your tax dollars are being spent on programs that we really don't need.

    I Agree I Disagree ×

    Get Heritage In Your Inbox — FREE!

    Heritage Foundation e-mails keep you updated on the ongoing policy battles in Washington and around the country.

    ×