• The Heritage Network
    • Resize:
    • A
    • A
    • A
  • Donate
  • Solar Subsidies Fail to Create Green Jobs, Again

    Wind generators

    As we reported in today’s Morning Bell ABC News reports that despite massive amounts of stimulus funding being spent on wind farms—nearly $2 billion—the vast majority (80%) of it has been spent on overseas companies. ABC contacted Russ Choma at the Investigative Reporting Workshop who suggested that the project has resulted in nearly 6,000 jobs for overseas manufacturers and only a few hundred over here.

    To add insult to injury, ABC’s Jonathan Karl reports that “a recent report by American Wind Energy Association showed a drop in U.S. wind manufacturing jobs last year.” That’s right—even with a government-subsidized demand, wind manufacturing decreased.

    As Foundry readers may remember, this not the first time that China has benefited from a country deciding to waste its money subsidizing the green projects. Derek Scissors reported back in August how Chinese companies were benefiting from Germany’s decision to heavily subsidize solar power.

    But protectionism isn’t the answer—the plan would be a stinker even if we managed to keep all the manufacturing inside the United States. As Nick Lorris explained last month, “green jobs” have a bad track record when it comes to creating jobs here in this country:

    In Baltimore, for instance, stimulus dollars have been spent to patch roads, install newer furnaces and painting rooftops white to conserve energy. According to the Washington Post’s Alec MacGillis, none of these projects, as well as others, have created a single job. Another example is in the state of Indiana, where companies have “weatherized 82 homes out of its three-year goal of 25,000, and reported zero new jobs from the spending.”

    Similar examples are legion. The point is that when and if renewable energy becomes cost-efficient, it will be adopted by private industry and wont need subsidies. Government intervention in the energy field only serves to elevate certain players—regardless of their efficiency and cost—above others. As we wrote last week:

    And the reason the government has to pick winners is because the losers (coal, natural gas, and nuclear) supply electricity at a much cheaper rate. So not only do Americans have to fund the construction of windmills as taxpayers, they’ll also have to pay as energy consumers for pricier electricity. This is not creating competition; it’s market distortion.

    In light of this news, the folks at the Department of Energy must be pretty embarrassed, right? Think again:

    Matt Rogers, the senior adviser to the Secretary of Energy for the Recovery Act, denied there was a problem.

    “The recovery act is creating jobs in the U.S. for American workers,” said Rogers, “That is what the recovery act is about, that is what it is doing. Every dollar from the recovery act is going to create jobs for the American workers here in the U.S.”

    This just further highlights the disconnect between the Administration and many Americans. While this White House continues to boast about all the jobs “saved or created” by the stimulus bill, Americans continue to respond with one refrain: “Where are the jobs?” It seems that even when the evidence of the failed stimulus is in front of them, it isn’t enough to convince this Administration that they need to reevaluate their policies.

    Posted in Economics [slideshow_deploy]

    13 Responses to Solar Subsidies Fail to Create Green Jobs, Again

    1. Pingback: How to Keep the Environment Clean | Topic Earth

    2. Pingback: Recycle Your Second Hand Clothes | Solar Power in Connecticut

    3. Pingback: Theme: Energy Reduction » Noise and Vibration Control

    4. Pingback: The New 3 R’s | Solar Power

    5. Pingback: PA Pundits - International

    6. Pingback: Fausta’s Blog » Blog Archive » Obama: “fierce advocate” for the free market

    7. Mark from Florida says:

      Just like healthcare, this is only a communication problem. Obama hasn't spoken to the American people enough about solar energy. Sure you use things like logic to explain the disfunctionality in the governements plan. If Obama could just "talk" to the people more they would understand that solar power = change and hope for the future, and after all isn't that what America wants?

      • LarryG says:

        So just what does solar power give us in the way of energy at affordable cost? Nothing! Talk until your tonsils explode and it won't change. It certainly doesn't enhance the jobs outlook no matter how much lip smacking occurs. Dope and Derange. Communicate and be damned. If one could literally eat words, Obumbledick could feed the entire nation every day. SCOAMF!

    8. Rich Stewart, Carlis says:

      There is a fundamental issue with all of these "green " and "renewable" energy science projects that these nitwits have foisted upon the taxpayers. None of them can be scaled up to a level that will make them viable commercial sources of energy. The technology does not exist today for any of them and may never be attainable for most, if not all, of them. Most of these things at best can only ever fill a niche in the overall scheme of our energy requirements.

      If there were to be an open investigation into much of this I suspect there would be criminal findings aplenty. While there may be some criminal stupidity involved, for the most part the pushers of this technological junk know full well it won't work and are profiting from this fraud and waste.

    9. Sam, Bangalore says:

      Green Tech startups are not manpower driven, but are technology driven. But its pretty certain that if we are able to make power accessible and affordable with green tech + solar, we can create a lot more jobs indirectly.

      Sam, Promoter of Green Living
      http://www.commonfloor.com/green-living?f=sm40

    10. Pingback: Iraq’s Largest Oil Refinery Shut Down After Terrorists Kill 4 People & Bomb Facility | The Gateway Pundit

    11. Pingback: Conservative News from Conservative Bloggers » Blog Archive » Iraq’s Largest Oil Refinery Shut Down After Terrorists Kill 4 People & Bomb Facility

    12. Kathy says:

      President Obama is due to speak in St. Louis, MO on Oct. 4, 2011, hosted by Missouri's Secretary of State, Robin Carnahan (recipient of George Soros's S.O.S. money) – dinner $20,000 / plate with her brother Rep. Russ Carnahan and her little brother, Tom Carnahan, whose company Capitol Wind Energy received sizable amounts of stimulus money. Hmmmm. . . .

    Comments are subject to approval and moderation. We remind everyone that The Heritage Foundation promotes a civil society where ideas and debate flourish. Please be respectful of each other and the subjects of any criticism. While we may not always agree on policy, we should all agree that being appropriately informed is everyone's intention visiting this site. Profanity, lewdness, personal attacks, and other forms of incivility will not be tolerated. Please keep your thoughts brief and avoid ALL CAPS. While we respect your first amendment rights, we are obligated to our readers to maintain these standards. Thanks for joining the conversation.

    Big Government Is NOT the Answer

    Your tax dollars are being spent on programs that we really don't need.

    I Agree I Disagree ×

    Get Heritage In Your Inbox — FREE!

    Heritage Foundation e-mails keep you updated on the ongoing policy battles in Washington and around the country.

    ×