• The Heritage Network
    • Resize:
    • A
    • A
    • A
  • Donate
  • The Truth of Obama's Trojan Horse

    The Wall Street Journal reports today:

    The reason left-flank Democrats are so adamant about a public option is because they know it is an opening wedge for the government to dominate U.S. health care. That’s also why the health-care industry, business groups, some moderates and most Republicans are opposed. Team Obama likes the policies of the first group but wants the political support of the second. And they’re trying to solve this Newtonian problem — irresistible forces, immovable objects — by becoming less and less candid about the changes they really favor.

    A rhetorical gong Mr. Obama has been banging a lot lately is the idea that the people pointing all this out are liars. ‘When you hear the naysayers claim that I’m trying to bring about government-run health care,’ he said in one speech, ‘know this: They’re not telling the truth.’ He adds that opposition to a public option isn’t ‘based on any evidence’ and that it is ‘illegitimate’ to argue that his program is ‘is somehow a Trojan horse for a single-payer system.’

    So much for changing the political tone. Perhaps the President should check in with his more honest liberal allies. Jacob Hacker, now a professor of political science at Berkeley, came up with the intellectual architecture for the public option when he was a graduate student in the 1990s. ‘Someone once said to me, “This is a Trojan horse for single payer,” and I said, “Well, it’s not a Trojan horse, right? It’s just right there,”‘ Mr. Hacker explained in a speech last year. ‘I’m telling you, we’re going to get there, over time, slowly.’”

    The WSJ is 100% correct: the public option is a Trojan Horse for single-payer health care. We are very familiar with Hacker’s stealth plan for single-payer and are well aware that President Obama has adopted it.

    Don’t believe us?

    Here is the Washington Post’s blogger Ezra Klein admitting the exact same thing: “They have a sneaky strategy the point of which is to put in place something that over time the natural incentives within its own market will move it to single payer.”

    Here is New York Times columnist Paul Krugman admitting the same thing: “…the only reason not to do [single-payer] is that politically it’s hard to do in one step…You’d have to convince people to completely give up the insurance they have, whereas something that let’s people keep the insurance they have but then offers the option of a public plan, that may evolve into single-payer, but you can do it politically…”

    The public option is is single-payer health care by stealth. It is time the President was honest with the American people and admitted it.

    Posted in Obamacare [slideshow_deploy]

    21 Responses to The Truth of Obama's Trojan Horse

    1. J.C. Hughes, Texas says:

      Liberal know-it-alls have always been contemptuous of the American people. Theirs is an egocentric sociopathy unique to both leftist and criminal con-artist alike. Who else would play bait and switch behind the back of the American public? How about a Messiah from the shadows of Chicago's powerhouse politics.

    2. Hoss at Big Guv, Tam says:

      That's Obama's Saul Alinsky doublespeak for you. It's so ingrained in his being perhaps he doesn't recognize he's doublespeaking (also known as lying.)

      But more important: this part really is the focal point for me: "He adds that opposition to a public option isn’t 'based on any evidence.'"

      UK's & Canada's lack of innovation, poor quality & rationed care is not evidence? Hundreds of years of evidence that support that innovations flourish in free markets while efforts by centrally-controlled governments are complete failures? That gov-run Medicare/Medicaid are among the most poorly run agencies in the gov? That gov/private monopolies like Fannie & Freddie are likewise dangerously run?

      These truths can't be entered as evidence in the court of ObamaDebate? These somehow are not valuable precedents available for examination?

      And where, pray-tell, is the evidence that Governments are better innovators, better at driving down costs while increasing quality? Is there any precedent for that!

      I agree with Obama's insinuated claim: Let's use evidence!

      Is there ANYONE in the media calling Obama & Congres out on — not their policies, or even their double speak — but their false intellectual superiority?

      False because they position their reasoning as that of being 'rational' & 'evidence-based' yet they deny all obvious evidence offered by others and offer no evidence or precedent themselves. They provide only the feel-good faith of "doing something" for their cause?

      When will the media ask the Administration and Congress "what precedents do you look to that give you confidence this is the right path to take?"


    3. capecodgabby says:

      Educated people who are following this " Trojan" horse know the real deal ( or should I say raw deal)on Obamacare.The sad truth is, ALL Americans will be kicked by that same Trojan horse and FORCED to pick up it's " road apples" along the way.

      When are people going to revolt? I hear so MUCH anger in regards to Congress and Obama ( DEMS AND GOP INCLUDED )People are FED up and it's going to get realllly ugly in the streets of the USA if these dirtbags continue to screw us taxpayers over with smoke and mirrors!

    4. Pingback: The Truth of Obama’s Trojan Horse « Conservative Thoughts and Profundity

    5. Pingback: » Financial News Update - 07/09/09 NoisyRoom.net: “Extremism in the defense of liberty is no vice. Moderation in the face of tyranny is no virtue.” Barry Goldwater

    6. Jeff Brodhead, WA (s says:

      If the Feral Government ramming 'change' down American's throats doesn't meet most any definition of "government managed", we need to send Obama a new dictionary (or an good old one.)

      We can't afford insurance now. Add 15 layers of government and lower the cost? Then add thousands in direct and indirect cap-n trade taxes and having to bring the kids home, for home-schooling and hyper-inflation (coming 'round the corner)…

      We may all run for Congress and be set for life!

    7. Dave O, VA says:

      What's happened to the Left in this country? Used to be the Left was about personal freedom and small government. Man, how things have changed. Think it could be from the brainwashing by schools, colleges and media?

      Now the Left thinks the only solutions come from government. They are quick to turn over their freedoms to the very government they used to mistrust. They have demonized the corporations (insurance companies). Hey Left, corporations are us; they are extensions of individuals. Either people have power or the government has it. Don’t turn our freedom on health care issues over to the government.

      Health insurance should be solved in a manner similar to other forms of insurance (life, car, home). 1) Establish government rules for coverage, fairness, corporate financial stability and affordability for varied income levels then, 2) turn it over to the insurance companies to figure out how to make it happen and compete for our business. They’re bright people, they’ll figure it out.

      Get health care insurance out of the employers' domain and put it in the hands of the public. We'll shop around as we do our other insurances. Take the government as a health insurance provider/payer totally out of the equation. Think of all the local, county, state and federal taxes that wouldn’t have to be collected to pay for others’ health care. Huge chunks of governments’ budgets could be axed. Health plans would thrive or fail based on our ability to walk away.

      Put the challenge on the people and stop thinking of the government as the solution to problems. Tell us what needs to be done and we’ll figure out the how. That should be government’s role.

    8. Dave O, VA says:

      Of course, what I wrote previously or any other solution that gives people the power won't ever happen.

      It's not about people power, effectiveness, efficiencies, comprehensive coverage, etc.

      It's about the federal government's ability to control through authority and money.

      That's the bottom line.

    9. Brad S,, Detroit, MI says:

      Buy your durable goods now. They'll cost you twice as much in about 3 years. I haven't had a car payment in over a year, but I am seriously considering buying 2 right now. It seems almost contradictory to rational thought, but the way inflation works, your big ticket items – especially those built in the US – will be affected the most . . . (Business taxes are passed onto you – the consumer, energy taxes are passed onto you – the consumer, you get the idea.) Go to cars.gov to see if you qualify for the "Cash for clunkers" tax credit.

      I'm sure this government run health care idea will work great ! Just look at our public school system. We pay more per pupil than any other country in the world and what are the results ? I think we have dropped out of the top 25 . . . .

      Let's project that onto health care . . – High costs and dismal results . . . .


    10. Patricia Brahm, TN says:

      One step closer to Obama's dream of socialistic America!

      Not on the point, but…

      Has anyone even noticed or challenged why the President's family traveled with him on our tax dollars to G8 Meetings? How much did that cost us?

      It was obviuos they were not invited… and very classless of him to take the First Family. I did not vote for him or his family into office, and walking and parading throught Europe with him was very un-professional. Now they are going to Africa for a family visit on my dollars!

      The only good news from the conservative side is when this medical bill passes, every American is watching and voting in 2010! I just hope it is not too late.

    11. Charles-Odessa, Texa says:

      What Obama says and what shows in the bills that nobody has read in total are not in phase. He should give himself time to read the bill and time for the public to see what is there. The lobbyist, unions, and company hacks who write these bills are not in the public interest nor are the responsible. The do it backwards. In your budget-you know what monies are available and then your needs and then your wants. Obama speak is Dream what you want, your needs are covered, and to hell with the cost. That is the short term answer.

    12. Marshall Hill MI. says:

      So when did TRUTH stop OBAMA?

    13. Dennis A. Social Cir says:

      The dems and obama are blowing smoke and telling us the woods are on fire. That is the same as peeing on my leg and telling me it is raining. We need to get this bunch out of office as soon as possible, yesterday was way to late.

      People need to wake up and tell them we will no longer put with their BS.

    14. Barry - Floral City says:

      By next year I see a grassroots movement to demand impeachment of the President developing if he continues to take this nation down the road to ruin. Our U.S. Senator Bill Nelson needs to go, as well. He clearly took too many cosmic rays when he was an astronaut.

    15. Metalchemist, Califo says:

      A GREAT leader fore father and the Third President of The United States(1801–1809), the principal author of the Declaration of Independence, Who many of whom's words hold true today said,

      An ENEMY generally says and believes what he wishes. This is exactly what Obama is doing, as he IS the enemy of this great nation. As is evident by the controlling of the media, seripititiuos as it may be. His press secretary constantly putting a different spin on bad situations, usually starting with "What they meant to say was…." Like I have said since Obaaaama was elected, "The great unifier is neither."

      When all is said and done there will be allot of people going to prison instead of returning to politics.(The very same ones that refuse to read the bills they are forcing upon the American Citizens, and turning a DEAF EAR to their constituents voices.) They are ALL duplicitous in the destruction of this economy and of this country we LOVE and RESPECT AMERICA.

    16. Ross, Bradenton, Florida says:

      Pathological liars will lie even when the truth stares them in the face. The lies are not important, getting caught is. Pathological liars are absolute masters of sophistry and deception.

      One observation; too many of them seem to reside in Washington, D.C. seeking and hell-bent on robbing the American people of the opportunity to seek our own individual life, liberty, and the pursuit of happiness unfedered by government.

    17. Ken Ballwin Mo says:

      I read somewhere that when 50% or more of the people learn that they can petition government, and government will acquease to their wishes, that its all over for that country. I don't believe that! However, we have to do something drastic fairly quickly before Obuma & Co. totally ruin America! My suggestion: And it will work and is possible. SECESSION Work hard on your states legislatures to Secede from the union. ( no benefits, and lots of drawbacks in continuing to be a part of the union! All federal property of every type becomes state property, ( real estate, money everything ) The savings in taxes would be more than enough to cover social security and medicare payments, with $ left over!

    18. Pingback: Myth 10. If you like your health plan and your doctor, you can keep them. « AAPS News of the Day

    19. Pingback: Fix Health Care Policy | It Is Time for Responsible Health Care Reform

    20. Pingback: Decoding Democrats' Words: Flexibility = Desperation? - AIP Blog - American Issues Project

    21. Pingback: Democrats public option strategy |

    Comments are subject to approval and moderation. We remind everyone that The Heritage Foundation promotes a civil society where ideas and debate flourish. Please be respectful of each other and the subjects of any criticism. While we may not always agree on policy, we should all agree that being appropriately informed is everyone's intention visiting this site. Profanity, lewdness, personal attacks, and other forms of incivility will not be tolerated. Please keep your thoughts brief and avoid ALL CAPS. While we respect your first amendment rights, we are obligated to our readers to maintain these standards. Thanks for joining the conversation.

    Big Government Is NOT the Answer

    Your tax dollars are being spent on programs that we really don't need.

    I Agree I Disagree ×

    Get Heritage In Your Inbox — FREE!

    Heritage Foundation e-mails keep you updated on the ongoing policy battles in Washington and around the country.