• The Heritage Network
    • Resize:
    • A
    • A
    • A
  • Donate
  • Medicaid Expansion Undermines Health Care Reform

    Sec. 142 Building on the Success of the Federal Employees Health Benefit Program so All Americans Have Affordable Health Benefit Choices

    (b) Sense of the Senate.—It is the sense of the Senate of that Congress should establish a means for all Americans to enjoy affordable choices in health benefit plans, in the same manner that Members of Congress have such choices through the Federal employees health benefits program.

    - Senate Committee on Health, Education, Labor, and Pensions, the “Affordable Health Choices Act”

    Should Congress actually follow this guidance from the HELP Committee throughout health care reform legislation, it is likely such legislation would receive overwhelming bipartisan support and thus be an enduring legacy. Unfortunately, as more details emerge from Congress, it is obvious that the policies being forwarded do not match the goal. Specifically, the expansion of Medicaid and how Medicaid will interact with the new Gateway, new premium credits, and other parts of the HELP legislation will undermine authentic reform. Rather than gaining access to the model enjoyed by members of Congress, tens of millions of Americans and the trillions of dollars spent to support them will be caught in the Medicaid trap.

    Congress to Discriminate Based on Income. The HELP Committee assumes an expansion of Medicaid to 150 percent of the federal poverty level. Since all states cover children at least up to this level through Medicaid or the State Children’s Health Insurance Program (SCHIP), the expansion generally covers adults. It is interesting that under Section 2706, health plans will be prohibited from discriminating against individuals based on health status, medical history, etc., but the federal government itself will discriminate based on level of income. Since eligibility will be income-based, an individual making $10 a month too little will wind up in Medicaid rather than having his choice of affordable health plans.

    Will Expanding Medicaid Perpetuate Health Disparities? The Department of Health and Human Services (DHHS) recently released a report on health disparities. It is unclear from the report how many individuals that DHHS believes are underserved are already covered by Medicaid. If individuals covered by Medicaid suffer from health disparities disproportionately, Congress should reconsider excluding low-income individuals from the reform promised to all Americans.

    A Game of Chance? Section 3101 will allow a child who is eligible for SCHIP to enroll in one of the new qualified health plans. In most states, SCHIP begins at 100 percent of the poverty level for many children. This sets up the following potential scenarios:

    1. a child living in state A lives in a family with income of 120 percent of poverty. An adult in state B has income of 125 percent of poverty. Because the child is eligible for SCHIP, he will be able to choose to enroll in the new program but the adult will not.
    2. a child and an adult living in the same state with the same income; the child will be able to choose the new program, the adult will not.
    3. a child and an adult living in the same household; the child will be able to choose the new program, her adult parent will not.

    It is obviously absurd to create these situations. But the potential for their creation reflects the unintended consequences of legislating in haste against artificial deadlines.

    Better Alternative. Expanding Medicaid is neither innovative nor fiscally responsible given the financial conditions of the states and the federal government. It makes authentic reform more difficult by discriminating based on income. A better approach is to integrate the majority of the Medicaid population, the children and their non-disabled parents, into the model being promised to all Americans.

    Posted in Obamacare [slideshow_deploy]

    2 Responses to Medicaid Expansion Undermines Health Care Reform

    1. Pingback: Medicaid Expansion Undermines Health Care Reform « Conservative Thoughts and Profundity

    2. shawn kearney, wyomi says:

      "but the federal government itself will discriminate based on level of income"

      Since when are the wealthy a protected class? I completely agree with the spirit here, but it is not possible. In the mean time, people are getting sick – regardless of their income – and low income people receive less preventative medicine.

      Discrimination cannot occur against the bourgeois. They are the controlling population by definition. This class needn't protection against "discrimination" as they are the oppressor, and this is why real healthcare reform simply is not possible. They feed on the sweat of our labor and any healthcare reform measure that is a threat to their profit will be smashed! This is why the health insurance industry's lies have become so widespread. Anyone who knows the facts can tell you, that beyond the old cold war paranoia and propaganda, a SINGLE PAYER SYSTEM is the only means to fiscal sustainability and equal access to the basic human right of adequate healthcare.

      But the greed of the bourgeois has been manipulated, and they have won. Though in the end, millions of Americans who feed the fat cats their hamburgers and french fries, who stock their shelves with big screen TV sets and clean the floors in their luxury apartments are without health insurance.

      So no, I don't care much about the higher taxes that the fat cats might have to ultimately pay – and why should I? We get a large return at the end of the year anyway. It is time that their greed come home to roost. They already can afford insurance and always will! And all the while we are the ones who make their bellies bigger and net worth higher from the sweat of our labor, supplying them with products which we ourselves cannot rightfully afford!

      We've asked in the 90's for equality. It's now time we demand equality! And if they refuse to end their greedful oppression, we must begin the revolution to form a more perfect society, free from the bigotry of servitude and oppression of bourgeois greed, who pretend to believe poverty does not exist! The future lies in the hands of the proletariat!

    Comments are subject to approval and moderation. We remind everyone that The Heritage Foundation promotes a civil society where ideas and debate flourish. Please be respectful of each other and the subjects of any criticism. While we may not always agree on policy, we should all agree that being appropriately informed is everyone's intention visiting this site. Profanity, lewdness, personal attacks, and other forms of incivility will not be tolerated. Please keep your thoughts brief and avoid ALL CAPS. While we respect your first amendment rights, we are obligated to our readers to maintain these standards. Thanks for joining the conversation.

    Big Government Is NOT the Answer

    Your tax dollars are being spent on programs that we really don't need.

    I Agree I Disagree ×

    Get Heritage In Your Inbox — FREE!

    Heritage Foundation e-mails keep you updated on the ongoing policy battles in Washington and around the country.